As close as it comes to an allpurpose anthology on holocaust and postholocaust theology, wrestling with god provides readings from across. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The main body of the work is concerned with van burens a theology of the jewishchristian reality, a systematic rethinking of christianity visavis judaism in a postholocaust world. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Holocaust theology is a body of theological and philosophical debate concerning the role of. Historically, postholocaust thought in theology and philosophy emerged primarily in the 1960s and. He argues that barths opposition to natural theology both helped him oppose nazism, and hindered his ability to understand the theological significance of the. Reading job as theological disruption for a postholocaust. Your subscription doesnt include the subject of this book. As close as it comes to an allpurpose anthology on holocaust and postholocaust theology, wrestling with god provides readings from across the full spectrum of jewish religious thought.
Dan garner ba hons, ma distinction, phd has taught in the department for religions and theology at the university of manchester for four years. This reference text book its a thick, scholarly tome, not intended for easy reading presents a collection of jewish theological writings about the holocaust. This book will be of interest to readers concerned with the modern reception of wisdom literature, theological responses to the holocaust, or simply the manner in which the bible has been used by communities attempting to make sense of modernitys darkest aspects. Philosophical and theological responses to the holocaust jewish. Jewish theological responses during and after the holocaust. Jewish theological responses during and after the holocaust kindle edition by katz, steven t. Christian responses to the holocaust this ebook list for those who looking for to read christian responses to the holocaust, you can read or download in pdf, epub or mobi. Wrestling with god ebook by 9780199885206 rakuten kobo. Since god did not prevent it, then god as traditionally understood either does not exist or has changed in some way. In examining specifically the postholocaust reception of the book of. It surveys the major themes raised by the holocaust and examines the most provocative and influential responses to these topics and to the holocaust itself. The overwhelming nature of the nazi atrocities and the jewish losses in the holocaust has compelled the post. Jewish philosophical and theological responses to the holocaust during the holocaust some six million jews were murdered and jewish life in europe was virtually destroyed.
May some of ebooks not available on your country and only available for those who subscribe and depend to the source of library websites. Jewish theological responses during and after the holocaust, was selected as the runnerup for the 2007 national jewish book award. Jews were drastically affected by the holocaust, in which approximately 11 million people. The volume certainly is not the only of its kind, 1 but it is unique in that it brings together in one volume the voices of european.
The most characteristic expression of traditional judaism is the halakha, or law. A reader provides a panoramic survey of the responses of over one hundred leading jewish and christian holocaust thinkers. The text is organized into ultraorthodox, israeli, and european and american responses during and after the war, raising all of the basic theological questions. This exacting, exciting collection bears testimony to the depths of. Within all of the monotheistic faiths many answers theodicies have been proposed. The theological view of the lubavitcher rebbe to the holocaust, and other jewish responses the center for theological reflection on the holocaust holocaust prayer at the united states capitol rotunda, national civic commemoration of the days of remembrance of victims of the holocaust. This book challenges and critically reconstructs ethics and theology by. Holocaust theology is simply shorthand for religious or theological responses to the holocaust and, although many are christian,2 here we will focus exclusively on jewish thinkers. The nature of this event, and the particularity and peculiarity of its assault against jewish life and jewish dignity, force a fundamental reexamination of all inherited jewish norms, not the least of which are judaisms traditional. As with the post holocaust theologians who followed, thinkers such as abraham isaac kook and mordecai kaplan mediated traditional jewish theology with the specific challenges of the modern world. His phd thesis was published in 2012 by gorgias press as antitheodicy, atheodicy and jewish mysticism in holocaust theology. Both jewish and christian postauschwitz religious thought must grapple with profound questions, from how god allowed it to happen to the nature of evil. Innovative jewish responses to holocaust the comparison project.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading wrestling with god. Gershon greenberg, orthodox theological responses to the holocaust, holocaust and. Beginning with a general introduction to holocaust theology and the religious challenge of the holocaust, this sweeping collection brings together in one volume a coherent overview of the key theologies which have shaped responses to the holocaust over the last several decades, including those addressing perplexing questions regarding christian. Part i brings together for the first time a major selection of ultraorthodox responses to the holocaust, written originally in hebrew and yiddish during and after the war.
Written by theologians, literary figures, cultural critics, philosophers, and others, these writings survey the major themes in western culture that the holocaust raises and the most provocative and influential responses to these themes and to the holocaust itself. In this edition, page numbers are just like the physical. Christian responses to the holocaust i told our lord that i knew it was his cross that was now being placed upon the jewish people. As with the postholocaust theologians who followed, thinkers such as abraham isaac kook and mordecai kaplan mediated traditional jewish theology with the specific challenges of the modern world. Ethics and theology after the holocaust theology research news. Part of the library of philosophy and religion book series lpr. The nature of this event, and the particularity and peculiarity of its assault against jewish life and jewish dignity, force a.
For example, some credit the holocaust with satanic inspiration or as an example of human free will and evil. Jewish philosophical and theological responses to the. Wrestling with god jewish theological responses during and. It is the most complete anthology of its kind, bringing togeth.
Speaking personally, the most profound jewish response to the holocaust i know is sefer eichah, the book of lamentations, the book written after the destruction of the first temple, the poetry of lament, bitter lament unto death. Judaism, christianity, and modernity after the holocaust irving greenberg jewish faith and the holocaust. Harold kushner made this view popular in his book, when bad things happen to good. Holocaust theology refers to a body of theological and philosophical debate, soulsearching, and analysis, with the subsequent related literature, that attempts to come to grips with various conflicting views about the role of god in this human world and the events of the european holocaust that occurred during world war ii 19391945 when around 11 million people, including 6 million jews. Following on the work done in his preceding two volumes, covenanted solidarity 2001 and barth, israel and jesus 2007, lindsay picks up the issue of natural theology and aims to move christian.
Katz, shlomo biderman, gershon greenberg oxford university press this volume presents a wideranging, extremely diverse selection of jewish theological responses to the holocaust. These writings show a profound, distinctive, religious sensibility that grew out of a deep commitment to the jewish theological tradition. The theological view of the lubavitcher rebbe to the holocaust, and other jewish responses. Some suggest that the holocaust should be understood using classic christian and theistic categories. Jewish responses to the shoah, to the holocaust, have been understandably multifaceted. Richard rubenstein, an academic and ordained conservative rabbi, is considered the jewish deathofgod theologian. Some pre holocaust responses to evil and suffering modern thinkers confronted the problem of evil and suffering long before the holocaust. God is dead if there were a god, he would surely have prevented the holocaust. Holocaust reader md responses to the nazi extermination oup new york the most comprehensive and representative collection of its kind, a holocaust reader. Oxford university press holocaust reader md responses. The holocaust as problem and promise for barthian theology, mark lindsay asks the question. Jewish theological responses during and after the holocaust edited by steven t. This book collects important and representative writings that respond to the nazi atrocities and death camps.
Responses to the nazi extermination features writings by theologians, literary figures, cultural critics, philosophers, political theorists, and others. This volume presents a wideranging selection of jewish theological responses to the holocaust. It will be the most complete anthology of its sort, bringing together for the first time. Philosophical and theological responses to the holocaust. Jewish theological responses during and after the holocaust first edition by katz, steven t. The nature of this event, and the particularity and peculiarity of its assault. Project muse the impact of the holocaust on jewish theology. Holocaust theology is a body of theological and philosophical debate concerning the role of god in the universe in light of the holocaust of the late 1930s and 1940s. Innovative jewish responses to holocaust the comparison.
The most comprehensive and representative collection of its kind, a holocaust reader. Others would suggest that christian theology itself must be revised, that the holocaust calls into question traditional claims about god, salvation, and human history. Some preholocaust responses to evil and suffering modern thinkers confronted the problem of evil and suffering long before the holocaust. Jews were killed in higher proportions than other groups. Jewish theological responses during and after the holocaust kindle edition by steven t. Feb 11, 2017 jewish responses to the shoah, to the holocaust, have been understandably multifaceted. Dec 08, 2006 this volume presents a wideranging selection of jewish theological responses to the holocaust. The authors have done an excellent job of picking the most important jewish thinkers about this topic and selecting representative examples of their work. Again, although there exist a few examples of religious responses from the. At even deeper levels and in more radical ways the holocaust is a christian problem. Idinopulos philosophical and cultural studies in religion imprint.
His research interests include holocaust theology, the history of jewishchristian relations, jewish. This collection of jewish theological responses to the holocaust presents a. The theological problems facing those trying to respond to the holocaust remain monumental. This book gives a critical assessment of paul van burens contribution to the jewishchristian dialogue, and attempts an original contribution of its own. The uniqueness of the holocaust my jewish learning. Though jews as victims suffered the agonies and deaths, paradoxically the deathofgod theology has had little impact among jewish circles. I liked that the book represented many different perspectives on the holocaust from.
What do you think the jewish theological response to the holocaust should be. Holocaust and the establishment of the state of israel in 1948. Jewish responses to the shaoh, to the holocaust, have been understandably multifaceted. The center for theological reflection on the holocaust.
May some of ebooks not available on your country and only available for those who. Christian and jewish responses 455 for both communities nothing can be the same as before the holocaust, though most of christendom remains unaware of this. Steven katz, shlomo biderman, and gershon greenbergs recently published anthology, wrestling with god, consists of an assortment of essays that deal with jewish theological responses to the holocaust. This revaluation can take a number of different forms. Christian responses to the holocaust pdf download full. Central theological responses the making of a rabbi richard rubenstein symposium on jewish belief richard rubenstein faith after the holocaust eliezer berkovitz cloud of smoke, pillar of fire. Was the holocaust a unique human evil andor a unique catastrophe in jewish history. The first published responses of religious writers, poets and thinkers who survived the holocaust were generally based on this paradoxthey expressed a traumatized belief which, standing the trial of the holocaust, was too profound to be pacified by any of the ready. It surveys the major themes raised by the holocaust and examines the most provocative and influential. In 1999 he was awarded the university of tubingens lucas prize for holocaust studies. Over the last few decades, this question has haunted both jewish and christian theologians. After surveying modern jewish and christian theological responses to the holocaust in chapters one and two, lindsay turns to barths no to natural theology in chapter three. Oxford university press holocaust reader md responses to.
Jewish philosophical and theological responses to the holocaust. In order to understand their views in context, it is helpful to see the breadth and scope of traditional jewish theodicies of evil, as well as to describe the roots of modern and postmodern. Revisiting amos funkensteins critique of holocaust. This book analyzes how such emotive reactions impact on the way religion is understood, exploring theological responses to human tragedy and cultural shock by focusing on reactions to the terrorist attacks of 911 and 77, the two world wars and the holocaust, the 2004 southeast asian tsunami, hurricane katrina and the 2010 earthquake in haiti.
1295 893 1156 1306 832 398 1030 1429 857 388 1391 439 1231 56 1416 1266 433 503 1513 149 344 486 858 237 308 483 1119 1511 501 72 852 601 758 604 630 1261 1050 1296 820 1059 83 828 1000